Prowess

SINCE 2002 · WOMEN IN BUSINESS

The Real Cost of Employing Someone for the First Time

The real cost of employing someone for the first time in 2025/26, from NICs and pensions to insurance and the legal steps you cannot skip.

The cost of employing someone for the first time is almost always higher than the headline salary suggests. Most first-time employers budget for wages and forget the rest, then get a shock when the first payroll run adds National Insurance, pension contributions and insurance on top. If you have built your business single-handed, the leap feels bigger still: you are moving from paying yourself when you can to a commitment that lands every month, whatever that month’s sales look like. This guide breaks down the real numbers for 2025/26, the legal steps you must complete before anyone starts work, and the reliefs that can take the sting out of year one.

What the Cost of Employing Someone for the First Time Really Includes

Salary is only the starting point. From 6 April 2025, employers pay Class 1 secondary National Insurance contributions at 15% on anything an employee earns above £96 a week, or £5,000 a year. The government has deliberately kept that secondary threshold low since April 2025 and confirmed it stays frozen until April 2028. As a result, employer NICs catch more of every pay packet each time wages rise.

So the true cost of employing someone for the first time looks something like this: gross salary, plus 15% employer NICs above £5,000, plus a statutory minimum pension contribution, plus employers’ liability insurance, plus payroll administration, plus the time cost of onboarding. For a small business hiring its first member of staff, these add-ons routinely push the real cost 15 to 20% above the advertised salary.

There is some relief available. Eligible employers can claim the Employment Allowance. It rose from £5,000 to £10,500 in April 2025 and lets you offset that amount each year against your employer NICs bill. For a genuinely first-time employer on a modest salary, this can wipe out most or all of the NICs liability in year one. It is worth checking before you assume the worst-case cost applies to you.

Legal Steps You Must Take Before Payday

Before anyone works a single shift, there are non-negotiable legal steps. You must register as an employer with HMRC before your first payday. Do this several weeks in advance so your employer PAYE reference arrives in time; leaving it until the week before is a common and avoidable mistake. You then need PAYE payroll software, or a payroll provider, set up and ready to run before the first payslip goes out.

You must check every new employee’s right to work in the UK. Depending on the role, you may also need a Disclosure and Barring Service check or specific licences. Skipping this step is one of the most common and most costly mistakes first-time employers make. Civil penalties for employing someone who does not have the right to work can now reach £45,000 per worker, and not knowing the rules is not a defence; only a properly documented check, completed before the first shift, protects you.

You must also give new staff a written statement of employment particulars on or before their first day of work. It needs to cover pay, hours, holiday entitlement and notice periods. This has been a day-one requirement since April 2020. It is worth drafting a template before you advertise the role, rather than scrambling once someone has accepted.

If you reach five or more employees, you must put your health and safety policy in writing. Even with one employee, you still need a basic risk assessment covering their working environment, whether that is an office, a workshop or someone’s spare room.

The Cost of Employing Someone for the First Time: A Worked Example

Take a full-time employee aged 21 or over, paid the National Living Wage of £12.21 an hour from April 2025. The rate is reviewed every April, so check the current figure before you finalise your budget. A 37.5-hour week comes to roughly £23,810 a year before anything else goes on top.

On that salary, employer NICs at 15% on earnings above the £5,000 secondary threshold add approximately £2,821 a year. That is before any Employment Allowance offset. Add a minimum 3% employer pension contribution on qualifying earnings, which comes to around £527 a year for an auto-enrolled employee. You are already looking at an extra £3,350 or so on top of salary.

Then factor in employers’ liability insurance, which is compulsory the moment you become an employer. It must provide at least £5 million of cover. Premiums vary by sector and risk. Budget a few hundred pounds a year for a low-risk office-based role, and more for manual or customer-facing work. Add payroll software or bookkeeper fees, onboarding time, and any equipment or training costs. Once you account for everything, the true cost of employing someone for the first time on a £23,810 salary can easily sit closer to £28,000 to £29,000.

Before those numbers alarm you, revisit the Employment Allowance. If you are eligible, it wipes out that entire £2,821 NICs bill in year one, bringing the realistic total back down to around £25,000 to £26,000 once insurance, payroll and onboarding are added back in. That swing of nearly £3,000 comes from a single eligibility check, which is why we would do it before setting the salary, not after.

This is why so many founders underestimate the cost of employing someone for the first time when they build their initial budget. The salary line is the smallest part of the surprise; it is the statutory add-ons that catch people out.

Workplace Pensions, Insurance and Other Non-Negotiables

Auto-enrolment is not optional. If your employee is aged between 22 and state pension age and earns at least £10,000 a year, you must enrol them into a qualifying pension scheme. You must also contribute a minimum of 3% of their qualifying earnings. In 2025/26, qualifying earnings run from £6,240 to £50,270 a year. You can choose a scheme provider, but you cannot opt out of offering one.

Employers’ liability insurance is equally non-negotiable. Operating without it when you have staff is a criminal offence that can carry significant fines. Shop around, because premiums for low-risk office work can be surprisingly affordable. Even so, do not treat this as a box you tick later. It needs to be in place from the moment someone starts.

Many first-time employers also underestimate ongoing admin. Payroll needs to run accurately every pay period, and you must file year-end reporting with HMRC. Statutory sick pay, maternity pay and holiday calculations all need someone who understands the rules. One detail worth knowing: if you ever pay out Statutory Maternity Pay, small employers can reclaim 103% of it, with the extra 3% compensating you for the admin, provided your NICs bill for the relevant year was £45,000 or less. This is often the point where bringing in outside support pays for itself. If you are weighing up whether to choose an accountant who can run payroll alongside your books, that combined cost is usually cheaper than the hours you would otherwise lose doing it yourself.

Support Schemes That Cut the Cost of Employing Someone for the First Time

There is help available, and in our experience it is the part first-time employers research least. Most women-led businesses in the UK are micro-businesses, often built by one person doing everything from sales to bookkeeping, so a first hire is a genuine stretch rather than a routine expansion. If cash flow is the barrier, it is worth checking whether grants for women in business could bridge the gap before you rule hiring out.

The Growth and Skills Levy, announced in 2025, will replace the Apprenticeship Levy. It will give employers more flexibility to spend levy funds on a wider range of training courses, including shorter technical programmes. Only employers with an annual pay bill above £3 million actually pay the levy. If you are below that threshold, you can still get government funding for apprenticeship training. Full funding covers 16 to 18-year-olds, along with 19 to 24-year-olds who are care leavers or have an education, health and care plan. Other apprentices receive 95% funding.

Apprenticeship incentives come and go, so always check the latest government guidance before you hire. For a first-time employer considering an entry-level or trainee hire, government-funded training meaningfully reduces the cost, particularly in the early months when cash flow is tightest.

The Employment Allowance remains the single biggest lever for most small employers, offsetting up to £10,500 against your employer NICs bill each year. Check your eligibility carefully, though, since the rules exclude certain company structures and sectors. If keeping costs down is your priority, claiming every allowance and incentive you qualify for should be step one, not an afterthought.

Getting the Paperwork Right From Day One

The legal and financial steps sit alongside each other, and missing either side creates risk. HMRC registration, PAYE set-up, right-to-work checks, a written statement of particulars, pension auto-enrolment and employers’ liability insurance all need to be in place by the time your new employee starts.

It helps to build a simple pre-hire checklist: register with HMRC, confirm your payroll software, arrange insurance, draft the contract and statement of particulars, set up the pension scheme, and schedule the right-to-work check. Doing this in order, rather than reacting as each deadline approaches, keeps the process calm and defensible if HMRC or an employment tribunal ever asks questions later.

It is also worth modelling the full cost of employing someone for the first time against your actual cash flow, not just your annual turnover. A new monthly wage bill, NICs, pension contributions and insurance all draw down from working capital every month, whether or not that month’s sales have come in yet. If you have not already mapped this against your numbers, learn how to read a profit and loss statement before you hire. It will give you a much clearer picture of what you can genuinely afford.

Finally, hiring is not purely a cost exercise. It is the point at which your business stops depending entirely on you, which matters for resilience day to day and for value in the long run. If you want to see how other women-led businesses make that transition, our facts and statistics on women in business offer the wider picture. And if you are weighing up whether to take this step now, read about why founder dependency affects business value before deciding how much of your time an employee should actually free up.

For more on managing the financial side of growing your team, see our guides on choosing an accountant, understanding profit and loss statements, and reducing founder dependency as your business scales.

Sophie Hartwell

An Editor of Prowess.org.uk and a business writer specialising in practical advice for women starting and growing businesses in the UK. With a background in enterprise support and digital publishing, she covers everything from business formation and tax to leadership, funding, and professional development. Sophie is passionate about making business knowledge accessible and actionable for women at every stage of their journey.

Related Post